142. You Can't Make A Living From Your Talent
I had a conversation with a fledgling designer who expressed concern over his pricing and how other designers with less technical knowledge were undercutting his rates and winning jobs.
He was obviously focusing on his compendium of software skills to determine his value when trying to attract clients and projects, he said that he didn’t want to work for minimal compensation because he had invested a substantial sum in education, software and hardware.
So we took a look at his skill set. He proved very capable in everything from page layout to web design, motion and photo editing, all of which are valuable assets and desirable skills — very marketable skills.
But from there, I took him in a new direction with this idea: Tools do not make a designer. A designer is a designer no matter what tool they use. They can use software or pencil and paper.
He was surprised at my statement. This was a new concept for him, and he was somewhat taken aback.
My basis for making that statement is that a designer should not be defined by their breadth and depth of computer knowledge, but by their ability to design. Design is not a form of self expression. It solves problems for people. It meets needs. It’s a service offering.
In serving our clients, certainly we can focus on having great technical skills. But clients don’t actually hire creatives because of their technical ability. They hire them because of their problem solving ability.
Absolutely a creative — whether designer, Illustrator, photographer — must be able to use the tools of the trade. We can’t produce our work without software and AI tools these days. However, tools are all about the production process, not design decisions. Tools are the how. They are not the what.
So I did some thinking about this and came up with a list of what a well-trained creative should be capable of:
First of all, a creative is a problem solver first and foremost. The client is coming to you to solve their not because you have stellar software skills or you’re a certified Adobe expert.
A well trained creative has the ability to create and innovate. Creating is bringing something into being. Innovating is putting things together in new and unique ways.
A well trained creative has the ability to research, glean insights, curate and edit the information that they gather. That requires critical thinking skills, first of all, to know what to research in terms of finding inspiration, and then to know how to put everything together, what to draw, what to abstract out of, what you learn in order to inform your design solution.
A well trained designer has the ability to make appropriate aesthetic choices. You need to know and deploy design principles, concepts of balance, pictorial organization, hierarchy, etc.
A well trained creative has the ability to explore and evaluate options. In other words, when you’re developing concepts, you must be able to to determine which concepts are more viable and more likely to solve the problem and which are not, and then to have the courage to set aside or discard those that don’t measure up.
A well trained creative has the ability to answer the what-if questions. What if I paired this with that? What if I looked at this from the inside out? What if I used a different color scheme? What if this? What if that? And not to overthink things, as I discussed in the previous podcast episode, but to spur further innovation.
A well trained creative has the ability to understand their clients’ needs and develop appropriate solutions for them. You have to be able to ask the right questions.
None of these abilities require knowledge of Photoshop, Grok, or Midjourney. None require knowledge of WordPress or Webflow. A creative practitioner is a person who successfully marries (and I mean marriage in the true sense of the word—successfully blends into a new thing) visual elements, organizing principles, functional requirements and whatever other constraints and must haves that the client communicates. Technical ability plays a supporting, not a defining role.
Generally, you’re going to attract clients on the basis of your portfolio. But your portfolio doesn’t necessarily show your process, and really, no client’s going to be concerned whether you’re using Photoshop or Revit or whatever. What they care about are the results. It’s what you do with the tools that matters, not the tools themselves. You cannot make a living on your talent alone, and you cannot make a living on your technical skills alone.
Creative talent is raw material. It’s potential, and it requires education, skill, wisdom, training and discipline to become something that is useful in the world. It’s generally understood and acknowledged that creatives have talent, but talent in and of itself does not solve people’s problems. It does not help businesses succeed. It does not help organizations attract more donors. So your talent as a creative, if you are serving clients, is a means to an end, just like you’re using your technical prowess is a means to an end.
You are more marketable when you become and position as a problem solver and prove your ability as a problem solver through your portfolio and how you approach clients — the types of questions you ask them.
It’s easy to sit down with a prospective client and talk about the things that they need, the colors, the fonts, you know, their brand persona, and things like that. It’s much more difficult to glean where the client is struggling and why they’ve come to you in the first place. Why do they need what you have to offer?
My recommendation to this fledgling designer was to rethink what made him valuable in the marketplace. Yes, his skills are marketable, but his thinking is key. One reason what his positioning needed to be revamped is because artificial intelligence is taking over the technical abilities that people are running their businesses on. A creative as a problem solver is far more useful in the world and has far more impact than one who offers only technical skills will become obsolete due to AI.
Be careful who you work with. If your prospective client is just looking for technical skill, they may not be the right client for you, and they most likely won’t be high-value for you. Pivot and reposition your marketing messages.
